Props are physical puzzles, tricks, and brain-teasers you can hand to your players at the table for them to actually physically handle.
Scytale: A strip of paper is wrapped around a cylinder, and a message is written across the paper. Unwrap the paper and the message is meaningless, rewrap the paper around a cylinder of similar size and the message becomes clear. Old like the greeks.
Deciphering: If you write the message around something that is lying on the table (A pencil/marker, etc.) then simply handing them the strip of paper should be enough. If you want to give them several options, then the strip of paper should be handed out either before or after the cylinder is found and the cylinder should be disguised (Hairbrush handle) and with a variety of other objects.
Mirror Message: No, not just writing a message backwards. That's dumb and simple.
You can bisect the letters vertically and write a message using the letters: AHINOTUVWX
Or, you can bisect the letters horizontally and write a message using the letters: BCDEHIKOX
(Use a Scrabble Word Finder to get words)
Deciphering: Once they figure out they need a mirror, they may use one nearby, if anyone bothered to purchase one. Alternately, you may hand out a mirror (or other reflective object) with several other items to obfuscate the text.
You can do this similarly with maps or secret codes using Catoptric Anamorphosis, but it requires some measure of artistic talent and a polished cylinder. On the other hand, if you have a reflective teapot, it can make a fascinating puzzle.
If I were going to attempt it, I would place the teapot/reflective mylar/tin foil wrapped around a paper tube, etc. on the paper, and sketch an outline in pencil of the map or message. I would have a good eraser.
|Alternately it can be a letter substitution, or letters can|
be missing from the cypher.
Deciphering: The key factor here, is that the substitution key must be presented. You cannot fail to mention it, nor should you provide more emphasis on its discovery. If the message is handed out earlier or later then the discovery of the message then the connection must be made by the players. The key can be obfuscated (as in an element of a larger picture, message, or image), but should be available.
Yes, you! If this is the type of thing you like to see, help make it happen! Join with the other great community supporters and Patronize Hack & Slash! In addition to feeling a warm, fuzzy aura of thanks for being such a fantastic supporter, moral superiority to everyone else around you, and superpowers (superpowers not guaranteed) you'll get writers commentary on each post and help us reach our goal that is only 10$ away! Only a (any monetary amount here, appropriate to your income level) will make a huge difference! Want to know what I think about crowdfunding and Patreon while I run a campaign? Check it out here.
Hack & Slash (See, saying 'patronize' is funny, because. . . never mind)