The Mystery
The central idea behind Horde of the Dragon Queen is that it's a mystery why these raid occur, and the factions have a vested interest in finding out why.Steve Winters says:
"Episode 2 is structured entirely differently. Characters are given a long-range reconnaissance mission where they’ll be on their own for days in enemy territory. No friendly NPC is standing by in this episode to tell the characters what to do. The situation is fraught with danger, but it’s all up to the players to decide how much of that danger they tackle. If they simply watch from a distance for a few days and then report, they’ll fulfill the minimum requirements of their mission. But how many players can resist the urge to take a closer look inside the enemy camp? This episode is all about learning how D&D lets players assess risk, solve problems, and interact with complex situations, possibly without ever needing to unsheathe a sword or roll a damage die."
Some of the most enjoyable sessions for players are those that involve them making a plan to infiltrate a place. This is a good idea!
The problem is, that for the structure of the 'episodic' adventure it requires that the characters restrict themselves to the primary mission. The characters want to sneak in and kill Cyanwrath? Too bad. Want to steal back the treasure? Nope.
The pressures on the design side of this are huge. Everyone has to have the same experience. These bullet points have to occur for the adventure to continue. The players have to have a good time.
How do you solve this as a designer? Let's take a look.
Introduction
Questman (Governor Nighthill) wants to pay 250 gold apiece for the players to accomplish these goals.- Where is the camp
- How many raiders are there
- Who their leaders are
- Why are they attacking
- Where is their next target
- Also, recover treasures
Then we get two paragraphs of boxed text to get you to go after Leosin Erianthar, a monk who is some sort of dragon expert.
There are a ton of real world logistical issues in a home campaign from this. In an Encounters session, everyone shows up fully ready and takes the quest.
In a home game, the raid ended about 5 am. An hour or two (short rest) later, Nighthill is asking you to track down the bandits. If you start this adventure at first level, there is no question that the characters are going to need a long rest. Does that mean they are tracking the bandits in the late afternoon? Why can't they heal the monk to come with them? As a Dungeon Master; don't many of those goals explicitly ask them to do things they can't actually accomplish in Chapter 2?
It's not that these questions are particularly difficult. It's that they come up as issue while reading the adventure. Set loose a group of real world players on the situation and there's no telling what kind of ideas they will have. I haven't run this part yet, so I actually don't know.
My personal answers to the questions is when the characters reach level 2, they feel tremendously refreshed and don't need a long rest, that the monk has several (3+) levels of fatigue, and needs more time to recover then the players can wait, and finally, that we'll burn those particular bridges when we come to them.
Tracking the Raiders
There are no issues with this! Good use of skill checks and informing the Dungeon Master of how to handle the upcoming information. The layout isn't designed for reference during play, but for a read through it's great.
Stragglers
The straggler encounter is fine. Players have the option to avoid, engage, etc. They may also end up with more prisoners which creates a bit of a logistics/moral issue. This isn't a bad thing, making these kinds of choices is what Dungeons and Dragons is about. As noted later, if the characters arrive after Sundown, it becomes more difficult to enter the camp.
Rearguard
The rearguard encounter is really good! The best solution is to not engage the group. They have an ambush plan. It uses terrain to good effect. It takes into account player knowledge.
For my personal campaign, it's important to note that these cultists are from the Black Wing of Tiamat, concerned with darkness, night, travel, and temples of worship.
The Camp
The biggest issue with the camp is that the confusion the cultists have over who's a cultist and who isn't a cultist isn't communicated very clearly by the text. The cultists have hired mercenaries, who have no association with the cult and yet move around the camp free.
 |
| Get High Resolution copies of Hoard of the Dragon Queen maps here! Support artists! |
Most players will spend a lot of time debating over what to do, which is made much more difficult being that the players don't have your insight into the setup and reactions to the cultists. I'd directly say something like this:
"From what you can see, the camp appears disorganized and chaotic. Morale seems high and security lax. If you wanted, you could probably just walk into the camp and nobody would bother you. If you did that there's a risk someone might remember you from the fighting in Greenest. You could also wait till nightfall and try to enter the camp then, but if you're spotted that will be even harder to explain."
The other thing I'd be sure to mention is this.
"The camp has a lot of people in it. If you are discovered or captured, you are free to fight against those overwhelming odds. Your best chance if that happens is trying to escape after they capture you before they execute you."
See, when a player approaches this problem, It is safe to assume the player thinks several things.
- There's no way for me walk into camp.
- You'll never take me alive!
The gameplay is in the camp. Bypass the part where the players have confusion over what the situation in the camp is, and get back to the interesting choices.
- Walk right in with a (very low) chance of being recognized.
- Sneak in at night with a chance of getting caught.
- Understanding that if you're caught, you'll have to escape, not fight.
As always, letting these choices be explicit doesn't limit any other options they come up with, nor does it guarantee success. Player skill can still be used in full force ("We use disguise to alter our appearance!" or "We surveil the entire camp so we know where things are!")
Captured!
I'm very happy with this section. There's no shenanigans. Frulam Mondath will sentence some people to execution, which might actually happen. No Deux Ex, no fancy contortions to keep the players alive. The biggest gift here is a single hidden knife if all other plans fail. The players are stripped of all their gear and sentenced to die.
There should be plenty of opportunities for real failure and here is one. They have to be both smart and lucky to escape with their lives.
Check back tomorrow when we talk about exploring the camp and wrap up chapter two.
Good post.
ReplyDeleteIn my game the party had a long rest between episodes. No problems there or in this part anyway. Liked that it was so different.
We just played this episode in Encounters this week and exactly what you said was the problem (I plan to do a little write up for my blog too, from the player's point of view).
ReplyDeleteWe found the camp and it was many minutes of standing around going... "So now what?" It was clear that the start of any combat meant death. The DM actually said as much. It seemed that every potential interaction with cultists/guards was a Deception check, which means that if you don't have a party with a good "face man", you were effectively caught and/or killed.
Similarly, sneaking in at night meant your movement would be a series of Stealth checks with the same results. A couple of bad rolls and the jig is up.
Basically, if you fail in a series of "roll-playing" rather than "role-playing" checks, you were done for.
Luckily, the DM at our table did not want to kill us over some failed checks. He let the players "act" (I use the term loosely) our way through some of the difficult situations. In fairness, everyone at the table was getting into play-acting the bluffs with the guards, etc.
But that brings up the whole player skill versus character skill debate. Instead of using our rolls, he let our bad acting rule the day, which I happen to like as a player, but there are those that would argue that he should have let the dice dictate the "truth" instead of us talking our way out of things when the dice went south.
Our table did do a pretty decent job of role-playing dialogue with the cultists, but honestly, the dice were trying to kill us all night.
I think it was a good call on his part to let us act it out instead of rolling it out, because D&D is a role-playing game, and role-playing is always preferable to roll-playing.
A rules-as-written DM would likely have captured, if not killed us, outright.
Yeah. I think just telling the players—you can walk right in, it's super likely no one will recognize you or even challenge you.
DeleteI should note that the module does provide support for not going on the adventure as it were, and I consider that a perfectly acceptable outcome.
Can I ask if I'm alone in having no idea where exactly the camp is supposed to be located? I've skimmed the chapter several times but I can't find an exact location. My PCs LOVE their maps, and I'm sure they're going to want to be able to mark where it is. The Sunset mountains look like a decent location.
ReplyDeleteIn a terribly late response to the map post (just in case someone else is in this situation) If I remember right the raiders exited to the east of Greenest? One thing I did when the campaign started was print out a big ol map of the sword coast ($2.50) and put it on some foam board ($.99). I gave it to the mapmaker in the group, and they have been tasked with marking additional points of interest on the map. Let them tell you where they found the camp :)
ReplyDelete